Will failure to pass state RES adversely affect efforts to attract renewable energy manufacturing investment in Indiana?

Dear Blog readers,

I received this as an e-mail follow-up to a telephone conversation I had earlier today with Doug Ahlfeld as I reported to him the progress of renewable energy legislation still pending during the 2009 session of the Indiana General Assembly. Many renewable energy advocates believe that we can and will get a better Renewable Electricity Standard (RES) passed by the U.S. Congress than the Indiana General Assembly. If we do not pass a state RES again it may have a negative impact on economic development efforts to recruit renewable energy industry investment in our state. We are hearing that those who make such business investment decisions want to see a committment to the renewable energy industry from the State of Indiana. Not only that but it may send the wrong signal to Sen. Evan Bayh as he prepares to vote on a federal RES as a member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee. The committee vote on a federal RES is expected THIS WEEK.

Yes, the wind farms may continue to be developed within our state because we have the wind resources but some of that wind generated electricity may be transmitted to other states to help utilities meet RES requirements in other states. But what about the opportunities for renewable energy manufacturing investments here in Indiana? What are your thoughts?

Laura,

The Northeast Indiana Partnership, http://www.chooseneindiana.com. who serves an 11 county area of local economic development organizations, along with the Northeast Indiana Green Build Coalition and Indiana & Michigan Power held a very successful wind energy supply chain workshop at the Grand Wayne Convention Center in Fort Wayne this past week. Nearly 300 attendees learned of the potential for building components as the automotive industry continues to diminish area business. At least 60% of the attendees were in an automotive related business.

One of the outcomes from this workshop was the possibility of turbine manufacturers moving to the Northeast Indiana area to take advantage of our manufacturing capacity. I met personally with Mayor Henry, who would welcome such a diversity in manufacturing to this area. However, one of the drawbacks we hear from turbine manufacturers moving to Indiana is the lack of a consistent policy on wind. They want to move to a State who has a favorable policy which will promote their business. I know of two companies who are actively looking at Indiana. As I travel to Chicago next week for the National Wind Conference with some of the Northeast Indiana Partnership officiers, it would be a great advantage to us in our discussions with these turbine manufacturers to have that policy in hand before the legislation closes.

The number of jobs which could come to our area ranges from construction, to service, to manufacturing, to large truck hauling and all the other related businesses with new manufacturing. This would certainly be a vital link to bring a change in direction to our area economy.

I wish you well with your efforts in bringing jobs and wind to Indiana,

Doug Ahlfeld
Board of Directors, Northeast Indiana Green Build Coalition
Education Committee of the Indiana Wind Energy Workgroup
Office 260-693-9380
FAX 260-693-0797
Cell 260-437-1478

Indiana Legislators Work on Renewable Energy Bills before Indiana General Assembly Adjourns April 29th

Two bills addressing important aspects of renewable energy are still pending during the 2009 session of the Indiana General Assembly. Compromise versions of both SB 300 and SB 420 must be adopted by midnight Wednesday, April 29 to become law this year. Both SB 300 and 420 currently contain language pertaining to a renewable electricity standard (RES) and net metering.


(NOTE: These links to the bills on the Indiana General Assembly website will allow you to view both the Introduced Bill and the Latest Printing of SB 300 and SB 420 plus amendments Filed and Passed. The eventual conference committee adopted will likely be a blended rendition of these various versions of the bill. You can also access the Roll Call records to see how your state legislators voted.)

A handful of state legislators will hammer out the differences between the Senate and House versions of the bill. The four conferees must reach a consensus assisted by a group of advisors from their respective parties in their House. Those appointed for this task include:

SB 300 Conferees:
Sen. Jim Merritt, Jr. (R-Indianapolis) s31@in.gov , (317) 232-9533
Sen. Sue Errington (D-Muncie) s26@in.gov, (317) 232-9526
Rep. Win Moses, Jr. (D-Ft. Wayne) h81@in.gov, (317) 232-9999
Rep. Jack Lutz (R-Anderson) h35@in.gov, (317) 232-9648

SB 300 Advisors:
Sen. Marlin Stutzman (R-Howe) s13@in.gov, (317) 232-9493
Sen. Jean Leising (R-Oldenburg) s42@in.gov, (317) 234-9054
Sen. Beverly Gard (R-Greenfield) s28@in.gov, (317) 232-9493
Rep. Ryan Dvorak (D-South Bend) h8@in.gov, (317) 234-9290
Rep. Kreg Battles (D-Vincennes) h64@in.gov, (317) 232-9798
Rep. Eric Koch (R-Bedford) h65@in.gov, (317) 232-0664
Rep. Bob Behning (R-Indianapolis) h91@in.gov, (317) 232-9981
Rep. Wes Culver (R-Goshen) h49@in.gov, (317) 234-3825


SB 420 Conferees:
Sen. Brendt Hershman (R-Monticello) s7@in.gov, (317) 232-9840
Sen. Sue Errington (D-Muncie) s26@in.gov, (317) 232-9526
Rep. Win Moses, Jr. (D-Ft. Wayne) h81@in.gov, (317) 232-9999
Rep. Eric Koch (R-Bedford) h65@in.gov, (317) 232-0664


SB 420 Advisors:
Sen. Marlin Stutzman (R-Howe) s13@in.gov, (317) 232-9493
Sen. Robert Deig (D-Mount Vernon) s49@in.gov, (317) 232-9523
Sen. Beverly Gard (R-Greenfield) s28@in.gov, (317) 232-9493
Rep. Dale Grubb (D-Covington), h42@in.gov, (317) 232-9987
Rep. Ryan Dvorak (D-South Bend) h8@in.gov, (317) 234-9290
Rep. Jack Lutz (R-Anderson) h35@in.gov, (317) 232-9648
Rep. Robert Cherry (R-Greenfield) h53@in.gov, (317) 232-9620
Rep. Wes Culver (R-Goshen) h49@in.gov, (317) 232-9753

Time is of the essence. Please contact these state legislators and express your support for renewable energy. Do it now!

After the four conferees agree to a conference committee report, it still must pass a Roll Call vote again in both the Indiana Senate and Indiana House. Therefore, your own state legislators will have one more time to support renewable energy in Indiana.

Since we don't know what rendition of these bills will play, STAY TUNED TO THIS BLOG.

Two Different Renewable Energy Bills Pass Indiana House

The Hoosier Environmental Council (HEC) provided this update on the renewable energy bills still pending before the 2009 session of the Indiana General Assembly. Now that both SB 420 and SB 300 passed the Indiana House, these bills return to their Senate authors, Sen. Brandt Hershman (R-Monticello) and Sen. James Merritt (R-Indianapolis) for further deliberations before the session ends at the end of April. Both Senators are likely to return the language of their bills back closer to the way they passed the Indiana State Senate earlier this year. Neogotiations will begin next week after Dissent Motions are filed and conference committee members are appointed. Watch this blog for updates!

House Passes First Comprehensive Green Jobs Bill, Thanks to Your Efforts. Your Help Needed in the Final Stretch!

In a bi-partisan fashion, Indiana's House of Representatives passed the first comprehensive green jobs bill in Indiana`s history. However, ultimate victory is not yet ours! House and Senate negotiations now take place on two different versions of SB 300.

The House version of SB 300, which HEC strongly advanced, would require that 15% of Indiana`s electricity come from wind, biomass and solar (not coal) by 2025 and would enable, in unprecedented ways, Hoosiers to produce more affordable clean, renewable energy at their homes and businesses.

SB 420, a competing renewables bill re-defines so-called "clean coal" as renewable energy, also passed the House. These bills will now go to conference committee.

Please continue your support in these last weeks of the legislative session by contacting the expected members of the conference committee and encouraging them to support SB 300, the HEC supported Green Jobs Development Act and oppose SB 420.

For a comparison of these two dramatically different energy visions, see HEC's policy brief. Conference committee member information can be found here. (This is the list of likely conferees since conferees have not been named yet.)

Click here to see the Roll Call on SB 300. 51 House Democrats voting "Yes", 11 House Republicans Voting "Yes", 37 House Republicans Voting "No" and the Speaker "not voting".

Click here to see the Roll Call on SB 420. 93 House Democrats and Republicans voting "Yes", 3 House Democrats voting "No", and 4 including the Speaker "not voting".

Citizens Action Coalition Urges Calls to State Legislators on Renewable Energy

We received this Action Alert from Citizens Action Coalition and wanted to share their views on pending renewable energy legislation with you. We also recommend entering your zipcode + 4 at www.votesmart.org to obtain information on your elected officials.

Please note that both SB 300 and SB 420 were recently amended substantially in the House Commerce, Energy, Technology and Utilities Committee. SB 300 was amended to add revised provisions from HB 1347 and HB 1349 introduced by Rep. Ryan Dvorak (D-South Bend). SB 420 was amended with revised language from HB 1305 introduced by Rep. Dale Grubb (D-Covington). Also HB 1360 was amended in the Senate Tax and Fiscal Policy Committee and it now contains substantially the language of SB 300, SB 201 and SB 420 as these bills passed the Senate on third reading during the first half of the session. Therefore, we urge that you review the new language in each of these bills.

Are you confused now? You should be confused and it is likely your state legislators will be confused, too. Therefore, craft your message carefully. It is unclear at this point which one of these bills will become the vehicle for a renewable energy Conference Committee during the last two weeks of the session. PLEASE STAY TUNED!

There are 3 different energy bills moving at the Statehouse dealing with the issue of renewable energy that require your immediate attention:

Tell your State Representative to SUPPORT SB 300 and to OPPOSE SB 420!!!

House Switchboard: (800) 382-9842

Click here for the direct office phone numbers and e-mail addresses of the Indiana State Representatives.

Tell your State Senator to OPPOSE HB 1360!!!

Senate Switchboard: (800) 382-9467

Click here for the direct office phone numbers and e-mail addresses of the Indiana State Senators.

Click here to look up your State Senator and Representative.

If you call the direct office numbers of your State Senator and Representative, you will get the voicemail of their Legislative Assistants, and you can leave a message at anytime. If you call the Switchboard numbers, you will have to call between 9:00 am and 5:00 pm, Monday thru Friday.

SB 300 will require investor owned utilities to get 15% of their electricity from renewable resources by 2025 and will expand Indiana's net metering rule to allow all customers to generate up to 1 megawatt of electricity and sell the excess power back to the utility. SB 300 will be voted on in the House on Monday April 13th. A clean renewable energy standard and updated net metering rule will generate thousands of new jobs for our State, save ratepayers money, and vastly improve the quality of our environment and public health.

Please contact your State Representative today and urge him/her to SUPPORT SB 300!

SB 420 is a renewable energy standard that defines coal as a renewable resource. The definition also includes waste to energy which will allow the incineration of tires to qualify as a renewable resource. SB 420 also forces us as utility customers to pay for utility infrastructure to ethanol and bio-diesel facilities. Please contact your State Representative today and urge him/her to OPPOSE SB 420! Remind him/her that there is nothing clean or renewable about coal and that we should not be expected to subsidize ethanol plants! Urge them to VOTE NO on any renewable energy standard that includes coal as a renewable resource. Please contact your State Representative today as SB 420 will be voted on in the House early next week!

HB 1360 is an atrocious bill that must be stopped. This bill includes coal, coal bed methane, and nuclear power in the definition of renewable energy, and will also allow the incineration of tires to qualify as a renewable resource. HB 1360 also forces us as utility customers to pay for utility infrastructure to ethanol and biodiesel plants, and would allow investor owned utilities to raise rates automatically with no regulatory oversight. But HB 1360 goes even further, by attempting to add new nuclear reactors to the Construction Work in Progress, or CWIP, statute. CWIP forces us as Indiana ratepayers to pay for the construction of unnecessary and enormously expensive power plants before those plants are producing a single drop of electricity. Wall Street is refusing to finance these plants, so this will boost utility profit margins at our expense. Please contact your State Senator today and urge him/her to OPPOSE HB 1360. Remind him/her that there is nothing clean or renewable about coal or nuclear power. Remind him/her that consumers are the ones that need protection, not utility companies with a captive ratebase, a monopoly service territory, and guaranteed profit. Please call your State Senator today as HB 1360 will be voted on the Senate early next week!

For more information about these bills, visit our website: www.citact.org

Thank you for your continued support of CAC's efforts to protect Indiana consumers, Indiana's environment, and the health of all Hoosiers.

Sincerely,
Kerwin Olson
Program Director
Citizens Action Coalition
www.citact.org